Friday, April 15, 2011

Grid vs. Cloud computing

In today's group meeting, we were discussing the security issues in the cloud computing paradigm. At the end of the meeting, I was confused about the difference between grid vs. cloud computing. Are they both refer to the same thing? Or Are they different? Or Are they have things in common? If it is the last case, what is common and what is different? So, I decided to look for the answer.

I am not familiar with grid computing, but Ian Foster et.al.'s 2008 paper titled "Cloud computing and grid computing 360-degree compared" helped to resolve some of the confusions I had in mind. This blog post is based on the material in that paper.

The following diagram shows the big picture of grid vs. cloud computing.

The following discussion is based on projects such as TeraGrid (grid computing) vs. commercially available Amazon EC2, Microsoft Azure (cloud computing).

How the resources are distributed?
To me both are the same from the distributed system point of view; both try to reduce the computing cost by using distributed cluster of computers. However, the main difference appear to be how the two approaches work. It is safe to say that, from a user's point of view, cloud computing is a centralized model whereas grid computing is a decentralized model where the computation could occur over many administrative domains.

Who controls?
In cloud computing (at least from what I have seen so far), one party has the control over the cluster of computers, whereas in grid computing, there is no one controller that can control all the nodes in the cluster. In other words, cloud computing allows a user/organization to build a virtual organization on a third party infrastructure where as grid computing tries to build a collaborative virtual organization that does not belong to one single entity.

How the on demand computation works?
Both have the notion of on demand computation. However, grid computing is more of an incentive model (e.g. if you provide computation resources, you also get computation resources from others who have already joined the grid/cluster), whereas in cloud computing there is no notion of incentive model. Cloud computing is more of a utility model like electricity consumption where you pay for what you use. One could argue that both have some kind of a utility model; in grid computing you trade your idle computation cycles, unused space, etc. with some other (same or different) resources available in the virtual network and in cloud computing, you trade your money for the resources available with a cloud provider.


I don't claim that the above description is fully correct. I may have looked at the topic from a narrow point of view. Please feel free to voice your opinion.

10 comments:

Aj said...

I always pointed to this paper to people who ask me the question 'what is the difference between cloud and grid. Some seem to think this is biased but its the only one I found to be a thorough review

Mike Bosch - Software Engineer said...

This is really what I am looking for. Thanks.

Anonymous said...

Well, there are more difference in terms of technicalities , such as data transfer, etc.

Anonymous said...

Well, there are more difference in terms of technicalities , such as data transfer, etc.

Jhon anderson said...

Cloud is one of the tremendous technology that any company in this world would rely on(cloud computing training). Using this technology many tough tasks can be accomplished easily in no time. Your content are also explaining the same(Cloud computing training institutes in chennai). Thanks for sharing this in here. You are running a great blog, keep up this good work.

Arjun kumar said...

There are lots of information about latest technology and how to get trained in them, like Hadoop Training Chennai have spread around the web, but this is a unique one according to me. The strategy you have updated here will make me to get trained in future technologies(Hadoop Training in Chennai). By the way you are running a great blog. Thanks for sharing this.

Hadoop Training Chennai | Big Data Training Chennai

kovalan Jayamurugan said...

Thanks for sharing informative article on Salesforce technology. Your article helped me a lot to understand the career prospects in cloud computing technology. Cloud Computing Training in Chennai

Chandrika Madapudi said...

Excellent post!!! The future of cloud computing is on positive side. With most of the companies integrate Salesforce CRM to power their business; there is massive demand for Salesforce developers and administrators across the world. Salesforce Training Institutes in Chennai

Blogger said...

Bluehost is ultimately one of the best hosting company for any hosting plans you require.

ssdn shivam said...

Hi
Thank you so much for sharing this worth able content with us.

Microsoft Cloud Services